Could It Be Magic written by Barry Manilow. Cover by Tyna Metzner Jun 24, 2015 Cover, Cover Barry Manilow, Cover Could It Be Magic, Cover Misc, Cover Pop, Greatest Hits, Ultimate Manilow, An oldie but goodie! Like 0 Thanks! You've already liked this « Vanessa singing Fallin-Alicia Keys (cover) » Bleed Like Me (cover)